{"ok":true,"service":"discovery-source-scoring-readiness","mode":"source-scoring-readiness-layer","timestamp":"2026-06-26T14:57:12.444Z","dependencies":{"discoveryFoundation":{"foundationReady":true,"liveSearchEnabled":false,"capsuleCompressionEnabled":false,"multimodalInterpretationEnabled":false},"providerRegistry":{"registryReady":true,"totalProviders":18,"liveProviderRetrievalEnabled":false,"providerCredentialsAttached":false}},"summary":{"totalDimensions":12,"dimensionReady":7,"dimensionFoundationReady":2,"dimensionReviewRequired":3,"totalWeight":100,"totalSourceTypeBaselines":7,"totalRules":8,"ready":5,"reviewRequired":3,"blocked":0,"scoringReadinessReady":true,"liveScoringEnabled":false,"automatedSourceRejectionEnabled":false,"vaultIngestionAllowed":false,"capsuleCompressionAllowed":false,"productionMutation":false,"reason":"Source scoring readiness is active as a non-destructive scoring policy layer. TheoB can define how future sources will be scored, but it cannot score live provider results, reject sources automatically, ingest Vault records, or compress capsules yet."},"scoringDimensions":[{"dimension":"source-authority","status":"ready","weight":14,"purpose":"Score whether a source is institutionally, scientifically, legally, or historically authoritative for the claim being evaluated.","safeguard":"Authority is contextual. A source can be authoritative in one domain and weak in another."},{"dimension":"primary-source-status","status":"ready","weight":14,"purpose":"Prefer original data, official records, direct research, first-party documentation, and primary evidence over reposts or summaries.","safeguard":"Primary-source status must be labeled, not assumed."},{"dimension":"citation-trail","status":"ready","weight":10,"purpose":"Score whether the source provides clear references, links, citations, datasets, DOI trails, or supporting evidence.","safeguard":"Claims without trails should not receive high confidence."},{"dimension":"publication-and-retrieval-date","status":"ready","weight":8,"purpose":"Track when the source was published and when TheoB retrieved it, especially for current or changing topics.","safeguard":"Old sources can still be valuable, but freshness must match the query."},{"dimension":"author-and-publisher-clarity","status":"ready","weight":8,"purpose":"Score whether the author, publisher, institution, or source owner is identifiable and relevant.","safeguard":"Anonymous or unclear authorship should reduce trust unless the source is otherwise verifiable."},{"dimension":"claim-specific-relevance","status":"ready","weight":10,"purpose":"Score how directly the source supports the exact claim, question, entity, region, or timeframe.","safeguard":"Do not cite sources that only vaguely relate to the claim."},{"dimension":"duplicate-cluster-context","status":"foundation-ready","weight":6,"purpose":"Detect whether many results are copies of the same original source or independently corroborating sources.","safeguard":"Repetition is not verification."},{"dimension":"conflict-level","status":"foundation-ready","weight":8,"purpose":"Score whether the source agrees, partially conflicts, or strongly conflicts with other credible sources.","safeguard":"Conflict should be surfaced, not hidden."},{"dimension":"commercial-or-seo-contamination","status":"ready","weight":6,"purpose":"Detect affiliate content, content farms, thin SEO pages, promotional claims, and low-evidence commercial pages.","safeguard":"Useful commercial sources can exist, but incentives must be visible."},{"dimension":"methodology-transparency","status":"review-required","weight":6,"purpose":"Score whether the source explains how data, measurements, surveys, experiments, or conclusions were produced.","safeguard":"Opaque methods reduce confidence."},{"dimension":"multimodal-interpretability","status":"review-required","weight":5,"purpose":"Score whether images, diagrams, CAD, maps, schematics, or datasets can be interpreted with enough clarity for structured use.","safeguard":"Visual meaning must not be flattened into weak summaries."},{"dimension":"capsule-readiness","status":"review-required","weight":5,"purpose":"Score whether the source can later become a TheoB Intelligence Capsule without losing source trail, uncertainty, or context.","safeguard":"Compression must reduce size, not truth."}],"sourceTypeBaselines":[{"sourceType":"government-public-data","baselineTrust":"high","recommendedUse":"statistics, public records, climate, agriculture, economic, civic, and infrastructure datasets","caution":"Check methodology, reporting year, regional definitions, and revisions."},{"sourceType":"academic-research","baselineTrust":"high","recommendedUse":"scientific claims, citations, research trails, experimental findings, medical or agriculture research","caution":"Separate peer-reviewed, preprint, abstract-only, and commentary sources."},{"sourceType":"encyclopedic-knowledge","baselineTrust":"medium","recommendedUse":"entity context, definitions, relationships, historical orientation, and citation discovery","caution":"Use as context, then verify important claims with primary or specialist sources."},{"sourceType":"general-web-search","baselineTrust":"variable","recommendedUse":"broad discovery, comparison, source finding, and contradiction detection","caution":"Aggressively filter SEO, duplication, weak authorship, and commercial motives."},{"sourceType":"news-current-events","baselineTrust":"variable","recommendedUse":"current developments, event timelines, public statements, and cross-outlet comparison","caution":"Speed is not accuracy. Preserve publisher, timestamp, and update history."},{"sourceType":"domain-specific-vault-feeds","baselineTrust":"review-dependent","recommendedUse":"cacao, climate, agriculture, supply chain, ceremony, sustainability, and specialized source streams","caution":"Separate cultural, scientific, commercial, and ceremonial claims respectfully."},{"sourceType":"multimodal-file-sources","baselineTrust":"review-dependent","recommendedUse":"images, PDFs, CAD, maps, diagrams, datasets, architecture, engineering and schematic interpretation","caution":"Require file validation, rights awareness, redaction, and uncertainty zones."}],"readinessRules":[{"rule":"Scoring Is Not Truth","status":"ready","purpose":"A score helps rank evidence quality, but it does not magically make a source true.","safeguard":"Scores must remain explainable and revisable."},{"rule":"Claim-Level Scoring Required","status":"ready","purpose":"A source can be strong for one claim and weak for another.","safeguard":"Avoid giving one blanket score to an entire domain."},{"rule":"Primary Sources Preferred","status":"ready","purpose":"Primary evidence should outrank summaries when the question requires factual grounding.","safeguard":"Summaries can guide discovery but should not replace proof."},{"rule":"Conflict Must Be Preserved","status":"ready","purpose":"When credible sources disagree, TheoB must preserve the disagreement and show why.","safeguard":"Do not hide uncertainty to sound more confident."},{"rule":"No Live Scoring Yet","status":"ready","purpose":"This layer defines scoring readiness only and does not score live provider results.","safeguard":"No live provider calls or Vault writes."},{"rule":"No Automated Rejection Yet","status":"review-required","purpose":"Bad-looking sources should be flagged before they are automatically rejected.","safeguard":"Avoid throwing away minority or emerging evidence too early."},{"rule":"Multimodal Scoring Requires Separate Rules","status":"review-required","purpose":"Images, CAD, schematics, maps, and datasets need specialized scoring criteria.","safeguard":"Visual evidence should not be judged with text-only rules."},{"rule":"Capsule Compression Requires Source Trail","status":"review-required","purpose":"A source cannot be capsule-ready unless its claim trail, uncertainty, and retrieval context survive compression.","safeguard":"A capsule must preserve enough truth to be reawakened faithfully."}],"futureSourceScoreShape":{"sourceScoreId":"stable source score id","referenceId":"linked future reference card id","providerId":"linked discovery provider id","sourceType":"web/news/academic/government/encyclopedic/vault/domain-feed/image/diagram/schematic/CAD/dataset","claimId":"linked claim id when scoring a specific claim","totalScore":"0-100","confidenceBand":"low/medium/high/review-required","dimensions":"array of scored dimension objects","sourceAuthorityScore":"0-100","primarySourceScore":"0-100","citationTrailScore":"0-100","freshnessScore":"0-100","relevanceScore":"0-100","conflictScore":"0-100","contaminationScore":"0-100","multimodalInterpretabilityScore":"0-100 or null","capsuleReadinessScore":"0-100 or null","explanation":"human-readable score explanation","reviewRequired":"true/false","createdAt":"ISO timestamp","productionMutation":"false"},"futureDimensionScoreShape":{"dimension":"dimension id","rawValue":"observed scoring evidence","score":"0-100","weight":"number","explanation":"why this dimension scored this way","uncertainty":"low/medium/high","evidenceTrail":"safe source notes or linked references"},"allowedNow":["Render source scoring readiness.","Define scoring dimensions and weights.","Define source type baselines.","Define future score object shapes.","Explain why scoring is not truth.","Keep live scoring disabled.","Keep automated rejection disabled."],"notAllowedYet":["Score live provider results.","Query discovery providers.","Reject sources automatically.","Write source scores to the Vault.","Compress scored sources into capsules.","Treat a source score as a final truth verdict.","Use text-only scoring rules for CAD, schematics, images, maps, or datasets."],"nextStructuralLayers":["Discovery Deduplication Readiness","Discovery Conflict Detection Readiness","Discovery Vault Ingestion Readiness","TheoB Intelligence Capsule Engine Foundation","Multimodal Source Interpretation Readiness","Visual Semantics Color Intelligence Registry"],"safeguard":"Discovery Source Scoring Readiness Layer is read-only and non-destructive. It does not query providers, score live results, reject sources, ingest Vault records, compress capsules, expose secrets, mutate production, or execute agent actions."}