{"ok":true,"service":"audit-trail-persistence-readiness","mode":"readiness-gate","timestamp":"2026-06-26T15:01:21.371Z","currentAuditTrail":{"total":5,"confirmed":4,"rejected":1,"productionMutations":0,"simulatedOnly":true,"currentPersistence":"not-yet-attached"},"summary":{"totalRules":10,"ready":3,"reviewRequired":7,"blocked":0,"persistenceAllowed":false,"reason":"Persistence is intentionally blocked until identity, append-only storage, retention, replay safety, redaction, and human review rules are finalized."},"rules":[{"rule":"Authenticated Founder Identity","status":"review-required","purpose":"Every real persisted action must include authenticated founder/operator identity.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Never persist anonymous real control actions."},{"rule":"Append-Only Audit Storage","status":"review-required","purpose":"Audit records must be written as append-only events, not editable mutable state.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Corrections should create new records, not overwrite old ones."},{"rule":"No Secret Capture","status":"ready","purpose":"Audit records must never include tokens, credentials, private logs, cookies, API keys, or raw secrets.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Only safe route labels, statuses, decisions, receipt IDs, and timestamps are allowed."},{"rule":"Retention Policy","status":"review-required","purpose":"Define how long simulated and real audit records should be kept.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Avoid indefinite retention without governance."},{"rule":"Replay Safety","status":"review-required","purpose":"Audit records must not be executable commands. Replaying a log must never trigger a real action.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Logs are evidence, not control surfaces."},{"rule":"Redaction Layer","status":"review-required","purpose":"Apply redaction before persistence so future integrations cannot leak sensitive material.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Default to safe summaries, never raw payload dumping."},{"rule":"Production Mutation Boundary","status":"ready","purpose":"Current receipt simulations explicitly return applied:false, simulated:true, productionMutation:false.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Real action logging must preserve exact mutation status."},{"rule":"Immutable Receipt ID","status":"ready","purpose":"Every action confirmation includes a receipt ID suitable for future audit indexing.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Receipt IDs should remain stable and non-secret."},{"rule":"Human Review Gate","status":"review-required","purpose":"Critical or safe-mode related persisted actions must require founder/operator review.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"No silent escalation into real control."},{"rule":"Storage Provider Selection","status":"review-required","purpose":"Choose storage provider later: database, append-only table, immutable log, or event journal.","requiredBeforePersistence":true,"safeguard":"Do not attach storage until access control and redaction are ready."}],"criticalMissing":["Authenticated Founder Identity","Append-Only Audit Storage","Retention Policy","Replay Safety","Redaction Layer","Human Review Gate","Storage Provider Selection"],"allowedNow":["Render structural audit trail.","Expose safe receipt summaries.","Show simulated confirmation and rejection history.","Review persistence requirements.","Continue non-destructive cockpit display."],"notAllowedYet":["Persist real founder/operator actions.","Write audit records to a database.","Store raw request payloads.","Store secrets, credentials, tokens, cookies, or private logs.","Replay audit records as executable commands.","Treat structural simulated receipts as real-world actions."],"futurePersistenceShape":{"auditId":"stable audit event id","receiptId":"linked confirmation receipt id","actorId":"authenticated founder/operator id","actorRole":"founder/operator/system","action":"normalized action label","mode":"simulation/live","confirmationStatus":"confirmed/rejected","productionMutation":"true/false","redactedImpactSummary":"safe summary only","rollbackPath":"safe text array","createdAt":"ISO timestamp","immutableHash":"optional future integrity hash"},"safeguard":"Audit Trail Persistence Readiness Gate is non-destructive. It does not create storage, persist records, mutate production, expose secrets, or confirm real-world actions."}